Chapter 7: The Man Who Changed## Chapter 7: The Man Who Changed the Birth Records
“Put the gun down, Arthur.””
Thomas stepped in front of Jasmine, the Birth Records
“Put the gun down, Arthur.””
Thomas stepped in front of Jasmine, spreading his arms as though he could shield her from twenty-two years of spreading his arms as though he could shield her from twenty-two years of buried secrets with nothing but his own body.
Arthur Whitmore didn't lower buried secrets with nothing but his own body.
Arthur Whitmore didn't lower the weapon.
At sixty-three, the attorney still dressed like a man who expected every room to the weapon.
At sixty-three, the attorney still dressed like a man who expected every room to belong to him. His charcoal suit was immaculate. His silver hair was neatly combed. Even his expression carried the familiar impatience belong to him.
His charcoal suit was immaculate. His silver hair was neatly combed. Even his expression carried the familiar impatience Thomas remembered from countless business meetings.
But his right hand trembled.
“You've never been good at listening, Thomas remembered from countless business meetings.
But his right hand trembled.
“You've never been good at listening, Thomas,” Arthur said.
“That's why this family has suffered so much.””
Ryan moved closer to Jasmine.
Thomas,” Arthur said.
“That's why this family has suffered so much.””
Ryan moved closer to Jasmine.
“You just threatened a woman holding a photograph. Put the gun down before you make this worse.””
“You just threatened a woman holding a photograph. Put the gun down before you make this worse.””
Arthur turned the weapon toward him.
“Another word, Ryan, and you'll regret it.””
Jasmine grabbed RyanArthur turned the weapon toward him.
“Another word, Ryan, and you'll regret it.””
Jasmine grabbed Ryan's sleeve.
“Don't.””
Her eyes remained fixed on Arthur.
“You said I'm the reason someone's sleeve.
“Don't.””
Her eyes remained fixed on Arthur.
“You said I'm the reason someone disappeared. Who?””
Arthur smiled without warmth.
“Your mother should have explained that to you.””
“Which disappeared. Who?””
Arthur smiled without warmth.
“Your mother should have explained that to you.””
“Which mother?”” Jasmine demanded.
“The one who raised me, or the one whose name you helped erase?””
mother?”” Jasmine demanded.
“The one who raised me, or the one whose name you helped erase?””
For the first time, Arthur's expression faltered.
Thomas noticed.
So did MarcusFor the first time, Arthur's expression faltered.
Thomas noticed.
So did Marcus.
“Arthur,” Marcus said slowly, “you told me the second baby had been transferred to a family.
“Arthur,” Marcus said slowly, “you told me the second baby had been transferred to a family in Savannah.””
“And you believed me.”” Arthur adjusted his grip on the pistol.
“You believed whatever allowed in Savannah.””
“And you believed me.”” Arthur adjusted his grip on the pistol.
“You believed whatever allowed you to sleep at night.””
Marcus's face tightened.
“I was twenty-nine. I made a terrible mistake, but I never wanted you to sleep at night.””
Marcus's face tightened.
“I was twenty-nine. I made a terrible mistake, but I never wanted those children hurt.””
“You altered medical records. You moved money. You helped create a false identity.”” Arthur tilted those children hurt.””
“You altered medical records. You moved money. You helped create a false identity.”” Arthur tilted his head.
“Don't dress cowardice up as regret.””
Marcus flinched.
Thomas his head.
“Don't dress cowardice up as regret.””
Marcus flinched.
Thomas stepped forward.
“Enough. Tell me where my daughter is.””
Arthur looked at him with something resembling pity.
“You still stepped forward.
“Enough. Tell me where my daughter is.””
Arthur looked at him with something resembling pity.
“You still don't understand, do you? This was never about one missing child.””
He pointed toward the photograph in don't understand, do you? This was never about one missing child.””
He pointed toward the photograph in Jasmine's hand.
“It was about two babies, one inheritance, and a family that would rather destroy itself than admit what Jasmine's hand.
“It was about two babies, one inheritance, and a family that would rather destroy itself than admit what it had done.””
Thomas felt his stomach tighten.
“Explain.””
Arthur laughed quietly.
“You want an explanation now? it had done.””
Thomas felt his stomach tighten.
“Explain.””
Arthur laughed quietly.
“You want an explanation now? After all these years?””
He took one step into the storage building.
“When Evelyn discovered she was carrying twins, After all these years?””
He took one step into the storage building.
“When Evelyn discovered she was carrying twins, her father was already gravely ill. His will contained a provision that would have transferred control of her father was already gravely ill. His will contained a provision that would have transferred control of his estate to the first surviving male heir in the next generation.””
Ryan frowned.
“That doesn't make sense. The his estate to the first surviving male heir in the next generation.””
Ryan frowned.
“That doesn't make sense. The estate belonged to my mother.””
“Eventually,” Arthur replied.
“But not immediately. Your grandfather had written a complicated trust estate belonged to my mother.””
“Eventually,” Arthur replied.
“But not immediately. Your grandfather had written a complicated trust agreement. If Evelyn produced a male heir, control would pass through him agreement.
If Evelyn produced a male heir, control would pass through him. If she produced only daughters, the trustees would retain control until the children reached adulthood.””
Thomas stared at. If she produced only daughters, the trustees would retain control until the children reached adulthood.””
Thomas stared at him.
“So the twins had nothing to do with his money.””
“Not directly. But the clinic director discovered that Evelyn him.
“So the twins had nothing to do with his money.””
“Not directly. But the clinic director discovered that Evelyn's father had secretly promised him a substantial payment in exchange for facilitating an illegal adoption. When the twins were's father had secretly promised him a substantial payment in exchange for facilitating an illegal adoption. When the twins were born, the director realized he could manipulate the inheritance dispute and profit from the born, the director realized he could manipulate the inheritance dispute and profit from the children at the same time.””
Jasmine's face tightened.
“You're children at the same time.””
Jasmine's face tightened.
“You're saying somebody treated us like property?””
Arthur's gaze shifted toward her.
saying somebody treated us like property?””
Arthur's gaze shifted toward her.
“That's precisely what happened.””
Thomas's hands curled into fists.
“And you helped them.””
“I thought I was protecting the family.””
“By making“That's precisely what happened.””
Thomas's hands curled into fists.
“And you helped them.””
“I thought I was protecting the family.””
“By making my daughters disappear?””
Arthur's voice hardened.
“By keeping a scandal from destroying everything Evelyn's my daughters disappear?””
Arthur's voice hardened.
“By keeping a scandal from destroying everything Evelyn's father had built.””
Ryan stared at the attorney.
“You let my mother die believing her daughters were gone.””
Arthur said nothing.
father had built.””
Ryan stared at the attorney.
“You let my mother die believing her daughters were gone.””
Arthur said nothing.
That silence was more damning than any confession.
Thomas took another step.
“Where is Amelia?””
ArthurThat silence was more damning than any confession.
Thomas took another step.
“Where is Amelia?””
Arthur's jaw flexed.
“I don't know.””
Marcus gave a bitter laugh.
“That's the same answer you gave me twenty's jaw flexed.
“I don't know.””
Marcus gave a bitter laugh.
“That's the same answer you gave me twenty-two years ago.””
“Because it's the truth.””
“You told me you had arranged her placement.””
-two years ago.””
“Because it's the truth.””
“You told me you had arranged her placement.””
“I arranged paperwork. I never met the family.””
“Then why did you threaten Patricia?””
Arthur's“I arranged paperwork. I never met the family.””
“Then why did you threaten Patricia?””
Arthur's eyes narrowed.
Marcus moved toward the filing cabinet.
“Because I found the original transfer order. I saw your eyes narrowed.
Marcus moved toward the filing cabinet.
“Because I found the original transfer order. I saw your signature. You didn't merely change the records, Arthur.
You ordered the second baby moved before the first signature. You didn't merely change the records, Arthur. You ordered the second baby moved before the first one disappeared.””
Arthur raised the gun again.
“Stay where you are.””
Marcus stopped.
Thomas looked from his brother to one disappeared.””
Arthur raised the gun again.
“Stay where you are.””
Marcus stopped.
Thomas looked from his brother to the attorney.
“Which baby did you move?””
Arthur's mouth tightened.
“The girl.””
Jasmine the attorney.
“Which baby did you move?””
Arthur's mouth tightened.
“The girl.””
Jasmine's breath caught.
“Me?””
Arthur shook his head.
“No. Your sister.””
The words seemed's breath caught.
“Me?””
Arthur shook his head.
“No. Your sister.””
The words seemed to drain the air from the building.
Thomas gripped the edge of the filing cabinet.
“You told me Amelia was to drain the air from the building.
Thomas gripped the edge of the filing cabinet.
“You told me Amelia was missing because she had been taken from our home.””
“She was taken from the hospital,” Arthur corrected.
“The story missing because she had been taken from our home.””
“She was taken from the hospital,” Arthur corrected.
“The story about the church was created afterward.””
Denise's account flashed through Thomas's mind. Patricia about the church was created afterward.””
Denise's account flashed through Thomas's mind. Patricia. The fever.
The silver pendant. The promise that a mother had never stopped fighting.
“Then why did someone leave. The fever. The silver pendant. The promise that a mother had never stopped fighting.
“Then why did someone leave a child with Denise?””
Arthur glanced at Jasmine.
“Because Patricia discovered the arrangement and changed the plan.””
a child with Denise?””
Arthur glanced at Jasmine.
“Because Patricia discovered the arrangement and changed the plan.””
Marcus stared at him.
“You said Patricia died in 2006.””
“She didMarcus stared at him.
“You said Patricia died in 2006.””
“She did.””
“Then explain the photograph taken in 2007.””
Arthur's eyes moved toward the picture in Jasmine's hand.””
“Then explain the photograph taken in 2007.””
Arthur's eyes moved toward the picture in Jasmine's hand.
For the first time, he looked genuinely unsettled.
“Where did you get that?””
“From the confession you thought.
For the first time, he looked genuinely unsettled.
“Where did you get that?””
“From the confession you thought we'd never find,” Jasmine replied.
Arthur's gaze sharpened.
“You shouldn't have opened that cabinet.””
Thomas seized the we'd never find,” Jasmine replied.
Arthur's gaze sharpened.
“You shouldn't have opened that cabinet.””
Thomas seized the opportunity.
“Why? What else is in there?””
Arthur's lips pressed together.
Marcus moved toward the opportunity.
“Why? What else is in there?””
Arthur's lips pressed together.
Marcus moved toward the doorway, apparently hoping to draw Arthur's attention away from Jasmine.
“You know what I think?”” Marcus doorway, apparently hoping to draw Arthur's attention away from Jasmine.
“You know what I think?”” Marcus said.
“I think you kept both girls alive because you needed leverage over Evelyn. One said.
“I think you kept both girls alive because you needed leverage over Evelyn. One child was hidden, the other was passed to someone who owed you money, and you used child was hidden, the other was passed to someone who owed you money, and you used the uncertainty to control everyone.””
Arthur turned toward him.
“You think far too highly of yourself, Marcus.””
“Then tell the uncertainty to control everyone.””
Arthur turned toward him.
“You think far too highly of yourself, Marcus.””
“Then tell us the truth.””
Arthur's voice dropped.
“The truth is that Evelyn found out what I had done. She threatened to expose me. us the truth.””
Arthur's voice dropped.
“The truth is that Evelyn found out what I had done. She threatened to expose me. I told her that if she went to the police, neither child would ever be found.””
Thomas felt a sharp pain in his chest.
“My I told her that if she went to the police, neither child would ever be found.””
Thomas felt a sharp pain in his chest.
“My wife knew?””
Arthur nodded.
“She knew enough to be frightened. She also knew that you would tear wife knew?””
Arthur nodded.
“She knew enough to be frightened. She also knew that you would tear the entire family apart if she told you.””
Thomas's eyes filled with tears.
“You used her love for her children against her.””
“I gave the entire family apart if she told you.””
Thomas's eyes filled with tears.
“You used her love for her children against her.””
“I gave her a choice.””
“You stole her children!””
The shout echoed off the metal walls.
Arthur's her a choice.””
“You stole her children!””
The shout echoed off the metal walls.
Arthur's composure finally cracked.
“And what would you have done in my position?”” he demanded.
“Your father-in-law had built composure finally cracked.
“And what would you have done in my position?”” he demanded.
“Your father-in-law had built an empire on favors, secrets, and people who owed him money. I was trying to keep the estate from collapsing. I an empire on favors, secrets, and people who owed him money.
I was trying to keep the estate from collapsing. I was trying to prevent the clinic scandal from becoming public. I made decisions that seemed necessary at the time.””
Jasmine shook her head.
“No. was trying to prevent the clinic scandal from becoming public. I made decisions that seemed necessary at the time.””
Jasmine shook her head.
“No. You made decisions that protected you.””
Arthur stared at her.
“You have no idea what it costs to keep a secret You made decisions that protected you.””
Arthur stared at her.
“You have no idea what it costs to keep a secret like this.””
“I'm beginning to understand,” Jasmine said.
“You spend so long hiding like this.””
“I'm beginning to understand,” Jasmine said.
“You spend so long hiding the truth that eventually you become more afraid of the truth than of the people you've hurt.””
For a moment, Arthur looked almost ashamed the truth that eventually you become more afraid of the truth than of the people you've hurt.””
For a moment, Arthur looked almost ashamed.
Then his face hardened again.
“Give me the photograph.””
“No.””
He raised the gun.
Thomas lung.
Then his face hardened again.
“Give me the photograph.””
“No.””
He raised the gun.
Thomas lunged forward.
A sharp crack exploded through the storage building.
Jasmine screamed.
Thomas stumbled against the filing cabinet, his shouldered forward.
A sharp crack exploded through the storage building.
Jasmine screamed.
Thomas stumbled against the filing cabinet, his shoulder striking the metal edge. Papers scattered across the concrete floor.
Ryan grabbed Jasmine and pulled her behind the cabinet.
Marcus rushed Arthur.
striking the metal edge. Papers scattered across the concrete floor.
Ryan grabbed Jasmine and pulled her behind the cabinet.
Marcus rushed Arthur.
The attorney stumbled backward, losing his grip on the weapon. It struck the floor and slid beneath a shelf.
Arthur swung hisThe attorney stumbled backward, losing his grip on the weapon. It struck the floor and slid beneath a shelf.
Arthur swung his fist into Marcus's face.
Marcus fell against the doorway.
“Get the gun!”” Thomas shouted.
Ryan stayed beside Jasmine.
fist into Marcus's face.
Marcus fell against the doorway.
“Get the gun!”” Thomas shouted.
Ryan stayed beside Jasmine.
“I've got you. Stay down.””
Arthur scrambled toward the weapon, but Marcus caught his ankle.
“I've got you. Stay down.””
Arthur scrambled toward the weapon, but Marcus caught his ankle.
The two men crashed to the floor.
Thomas moved to help, but Arthur kicked free andThe two men crashed to the floor.
Thomas moved to help, but Arthur kicked free and ran toward the open door.
He reached the yard just as distant sirens began to rise.
Ryan had called the ran toward the open door.
He reached the yard just as distant sirens began to rise.
Ryan had called the police before Arthur entered the building.
Arthur froze.
Red and blue lights flashed between the trees.
For one police before Arthur entered the building.
Arthur froze.
Red and blue lights flashed between the trees.
For one second, Thomas thought the nightmare might finally be over.
Then Arthur looked back at Jasmine.
His face had become second, Thomas thought the nightmare might finally be over.
Then Arthur looked back at Jasmine.
His face had become strangely calm.
“You want to know who your real mother was?”” he called.
Jasmine stood slowly behind the cabinet.
Arthur strangely calm.
“You want to know who your real mother was?”” he called.
Jasmine stood slowly behind the cabinet.
Arthur smiled.
“Ask Denise what happened on the night Patricia brought you to the church.””
Denise wasn't smiled.
“Ask Denise what happened on the night Patricia brought you to the church.””
Denise wasn't there to answer.
But Jasmine's phone suddenly vibrated in her pocket.
An incoming message appeared from an unknown number.
** there to answer.
But Jasmine's phone suddenly vibrated in her pocket.
An incoming message appeared from an unknown number.
*YOUR MOTHER DIDN'T FIND YOU BY ACCIDENT. SHE WAS PAID TO CHOOSE WHICH BABYOUR MOTHER DIDN'T FIND YOU BY ACCIDENT. SHE WAS PAID TO CHOOSE WHICH BABY WOULD LIVE.*
Jasmine stared at the screen.
Thomas saw the message over her shoulder.
His face drained of color.
Because beneath theY WOULD LIVE.**
Jasmine stared at the screen.
Thomas saw the message over her shoulder.
His face drained of color.
Because beneath the words was a photograph of Denise, taken only minutes earlier, standing outside her own front door.
And someone had words was a photograph of Denise, taken only minutes earlier, standing outside her own front door.
And someone had circled a second figure in the background.
A woman with Patricia Bell's face.
May you like
circled a second figure in the background.
A woman with Patricia Bell's face.
Related Stories